Judge Stamps Out a Cigarette Class Action
|
|
In a victory for the tobacco industry, a national of the appellate court in Manhattan has laid a class action on behalf of persons who have ever smoked “light” cigarettes. The appeal had $ 800 billion in damages on behalf of 50 million smokers. A three-judge panel of 2 U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals agreed, the appeal yesterday a reversal of the decision, the district judge to confirm a class of “light” cigarettes, smoking tobacco could follow several companies. The petitioners claimed that cigarette manufacturers to mislead to believe that in “light” cigarettes, candidates who have less nicotine and tar, were less bad than other cigarettes. The claimants allege that smokers who want “light” cigarettes, without knowing until the end as much tar and nicotine inhaler, and because they smoke more cigarettes to compensate. The Court found that it was possible that smokers of “light” she had chosen for reasons other than the health of the so-called benefits. The decision written by Judge John Walker, noting that some smokers may have “preferred the taste of enlightenment, or choose strengths as an expression of personal style.” The existence of smoking, “light” cigarettes for other reasons, that there is no single class in the action, the decision said. The 2nd Circuit decision, each applicant must demonstrate that he or she took the product because of the positive impact on the perceived health. While this requirement is not yet the end of the perspective of individual actions on the basis of “light” cigarettes, it is the end of the possibility of collective action. The defendants were the American Tobacco Co., Altria Group, Philip Morris USA Inc., Lorillard Tobacco Co., Liggett Group Inc., RJ Reynolds Tobacco Co., and others. The lawyer argued that in the case of the tobacco industry, Theodore Grossman, said the problem is related to a class action on behalf of all the “light” cigarette smokers, that “many people believe that “Light” cigarettes are just as dangerous as normal Cigarettes. ” Mr. Grossman, the Chancellery Jones Day, said, the number of applicants in the proposed class and the amount of the fine is “astronomical” and “unprecedented in American jurisprudence.” The lead lawyer for the claimants, Michael scope of the house, said that the various claimants would be to advance their claims, the district court in Brooklyn before Judge Jack Weinstein. He said that there were several complaints on behalf of “light” cigarette smokers in the state courts. |